The Pudding Mix Trick for CREAMi Protein Ice Cream
Why a spoon of instant pudding mix makes CREAMi protein ice cream creamy, how much to use, which flavors work and sugar-free or no-pudding options.
By the Dalqi kitchen · Updated 2026-11-16 · 4 min read

Short answer
Adding about 1 tablespoon of instant pudding mix to a 16 oz CREAMi protein pint makes it creamier and less icy, because the starch and thickeners in the mix bind water and give the base body. Sugar-free instant pudding works just as well and adds very few calories. Use instant, not cook-and-serve, and whisk or shake it in well before freezing.
Why pudding mix works
Protein pints are lean. There's little sugar or fat to keep ice crystals small, so the base freezes hard and spins powdery or icy. Instant pudding mix is designed to thicken cold milk without cooking. It contains a starch that swells in cold liquid, often along with gums and other thickeners.
In a pint, that means:
- Less free water. The thickeners hold onto water, so it can't form large crystals.
- More body. The base is thicker before freezing, so it spins into something closer to ice cream than shaved ice.
- Extra flavor. Cheesecake, butterscotch, banana or pistachio pudding mix adds a lot of flavor for one spoonful.
It's the single ingredient that shows up in almost every light pint we make, from the Vanilla Bean Protein Pint to the Light Iced Coffee Pint.
How much to use
| Base | Pudding mix per 16 oz pint |
|---|---|
| Standard protein pint (milk + 1 scoop) | 1 tbsp (about 8 g) |
| Thin bases (almond milk, coffee) | 1 to 1½ tbsp |
| Flavor-led pints (pistachio, banana) | Up to 1½ tbsp |
| Rich cream bases | Optional, about 2 tsp |
| 24 oz Deluxe pint | About 1½ times the amount above |
More isn't better. Past about 1½ tablespoons in a 16 oz pint, the texture can turn gummy or starchy and the pudding flavor starts to dominate.
Instant vs cook-and-serve
Use instant pudding mix. It's made to thicken cold milk, which is exactly what happens in a pint. Cook-and-serve pudding needs heat to thicken, so in a cold base it just adds a raw, starchy taste without doing its job.
Both regular and sugar-free instant mixes work. Regular mix adds some sugar, which also helps soften the pint. Sugar-free mix keeps calories lower and usually contains a non-nutritive sweetener; check the label if you avoid specific sweeteners.
Flavors that work well
- Vanilla: the all-rounder. Fits fruit, coffee and cookie pints.
- Chocolate: deepens any chocolate pint, as in the Double Chocolate Protein Pint.
- Cheesecake: the secret to Strawberry Cheesecake and Key Lime Pie pints.
- Butterscotch: perfect for Salted Caramel Protein.
- Pistachio: gives color and flavor in the Pistachio Protein Ice Cream.
- Banana: makes the Banana Pudding Protein Pint taste like the dessert.
How to mix it in
- Add the protein powder, pudding mix and a pinch of salt to the empty pint.
- Pour in about half the milk. Lid on and shake hard for 30 seconds, or whisk.
- Add the rest of the liquid and stir. Fill only to the MAX line.
- Let it sit 5 minutes. It will thicken slightly, which is what you want.
- Freeze level for 24 hours.
Mixing the dry ingredients with only part of the milk first avoids lumps. Undissolved pudding powder freezes into chalky bits.
No pudding mix? Alternatives
- Xanthan or guar gum: a very small amount, about ⅛ teaspoon per pint, thickens without flavor. Too much turns slimy, so measure carefully.
- Cream cheese: a tablespoon adds body and richness, as in our Classic Vanilla Ice Cream.
- Greek yogurt: adds protein and thickness, with some tang.
- Cottage cheese: blended fully smooth, it gives a dense, creamy base.
- A casein-heavy protein powder: thickens on its own, so you may need less pudding mix.
Common pudding-mix mistakes
- Dumping it into a full pint. Powder added to lots of cold milk clumps. Mix it with the dry ingredients and part of the milk first.
- Using too much. Two or three tablespoons in a 16 oz pint gives a gummy, starchy texture that no Re-spin fixes.
- Grabbing cook-and-serve. The boxes look alike. Check that it says instant.
- Clashing flavors. Chocolate pudding mix in a strawberry pint muddies both. Vanilla or cheesecake is the safe choice when in doubt.
- Expecting it to replace a Re-spin. Pudding mix makes pints much better, but lean bases can still look a little dry on the first spin. A tablespoon of milk and a Re-spin finishes the job.
Beyond protein pints, and the macros
The trick isn't only for protein ice cream. A smaller amount helps classic pints hold their shape, and it's a key part of soft serve on the Ninja Swirl, where it keeps the swirl standing tall instead of slumping. Our Vanilla Soft Serve uses it for exactly that. It also adds body to no-cook custard-style pints like the Eggnog Ice Cream, where French vanilla pudding stands in for a cooked egg base.
A tablespoon of sugar-free instant pudding mix adds only a small number of calories and carbs per pint, mostly from starch. Regular mix adds more because of the sugar. For the exact numbers with your milk and powder, use the pint builder, which totals protein and calories as you change ingredients. More pudding-mix pints are on the CREAMi recipe hub.
FAQ
How much pudding mix goes in a CREAMi pint?
About 1 tablespoon (roughly 8 g) of instant pudding mix per 16 oz pint. Thin or flavor-led bases can take up to 1½ tablespoons.
Does sugar-free pudding mix work in the CREAMi?
Yes. Sugar-free instant pudding thickens the same way and adds very few calories, which is why it's common in protein pints.
Can I use cook-and-serve pudding mix?
It's not a good fit. Cook-and-serve needs heat to thicken, so in a cold base it adds a starchy taste without improving texture. Use instant.
What can I use instead of pudding mix in a CREAMi pint?
A pinch of xanthan or guar gum, a tablespoon of cream cheese, Greek yogurt or blended cottage cheese all add body in place of pudding mix.
Recipes to try
CREAMiVanilla Bean Protein Pint
184 kcal · 24 g protein · Freeze 24 h
CREAMiDouble Chocolate Protein Pint
182 kcal · 23 g protein · Freeze 24 h
CREAMiStrawberry Cheesecake Protein Pint
217 kcal · 25 g protein · Freeze 24 h
CREAMiBanana Pudding Protein Pint
236 kcal · 22 g protein · Freeze 24 h
CREAMiPistachio Protein Ice Cream
232 kcal · 24 g protein · Freeze 24 h
CREAMiSalted Caramel Protein Ice Cream
216 kcal · 24 g protein · Freeze 24 h
CREAMiKey Lime Pie Protein Ice Cream
210 kcal · 26 g protein · Freeze 24 h


