Guides
Guide · Ninja CREAMi

Ninja CREAMi Mix-Ins Guide: What Works, How Much and When

How to use the Ninja CREAMi Mix-In program: the best mix-ins, how much to add per pint, ideal chunk size, when to add them and which ones to avoid.

By the Dalqi kitchen · Updated 2026-11-16 · 4 min read

Vanilla ice cream in a pint with chunks of chocolate sandwich cookies, cookie dough bites and chocolate chips folded through

Short answer

Add mix-ins after the pint has been spun smooth, never before freezing. Dig a hole about 1½ inches wide down the center, add roughly 2 to 4 tablespoons of chopped mix-ins (about ¼ cup) to a 16 oz pint, and run the Mix-In program. Chunks should be small, around the size of a chocolate chip to a pea, and cold.

Why mix-ins go in last

The first spin shaves the frozen block with a lot of force. Anything frozen into the base, like cookies or chocolate, gets chopped to dust. The Mix-In program is gentler and shorter, so it folds chunks through the ice cream without destroying them.

The other reason is texture. You want the base spun creamy before the chunks go in. If the pint is still powdery, Re-spin it first, then add mix-ins.

Step by step

  1. Spin the pint on its usual program. Re-spin if needed until smooth.
  2. Use a spoon to make a hole about 1½ inches wide from the top down to the bottom of the pint.
  3. Add the mix-ins into the hole. Spread a few over the top too if you like.
  4. Put the pint back in and run Mix-In.
  5. Eat right away, or smooth the top and freeze.

The hole matters. Piling mix-ins on top means most stay at the surface. Our Salted Caramel Protein Ice Cream uses the hole for cold caramel, which then freezes into ribbons.

How much to add

For a 16 oz pint, about ¼ cup total is a good starting point. Lighter, airy mix-ins like marshmallows can go higher; dense ones like nuts or chocolate should go lower.

Mix-inPer 16 oz pintExample
Crushed cookies2 cookiesCookies & Cream Protein
Chocolate chips1 to 2 tbspMint Chocolate Chip Protein
Chopped nuts2 tbspPistachio Protein
Cookie dough bitesAbout ¼ cupCookie Dough Protein
Graham pieces1 sheetS'mores Protein
Thick sauce (caramel, fudge)1 to 2 tbsp, coldSalted Caramel

For a 24 oz Deluxe pint, use about 1½ times as much.

Chunk size and temperature

  • Small is better. Aim for pieces from chocolate-chip size up to about ¼ inch. Large pieces don't fold in well and can be hard on the machine.
  • Break, don't pulverize. Crush cookies by hand so you keep real chunks.
  • Cold mix-ins only. Warm sauce, warm nuts or just-baked anything melts the pint. Let toasted nuts and broiled marshmallows cool completely.
  • Pre-freeze soft mix-ins. Cookie dough, brownie bites and cheesecake cubes hold their shape better if frozen for 15 to 30 minutes first.

Mix-ins that work best

  • Chocolate chips, mini chips and chopped chocolate bars.
  • Sandwich cookies, graham crackers, shortbread and wafers.
  • Toasted, chopped nuts like pecans, pistachios and almonds.
  • Heat-treated cookie dough and brownie pieces.
  • Cold, thick caramel, fudge, cookie butter or peanut butter ribbons.
  • Sprinkles and mini marshmallows, as in our Unicorn Ice Cream.
  • Small cooked fruit pieces, like the apple chunks in our Apple Pie Ice Cream.

Mix-ins to avoid or handle carefully

  • Large fresh fruit chunks. Fresh fruit is mostly water and freezes into icy rocks. Dice it small, cook it, or swirl in a cold compote instead.
  • Hard candy and candy canes. They go sticky in the freezer. Add them right before serving, as with our Peppermint Bark Ice Cream.
  • Cotton candy. It dissolves within a minute. Add it at the very end and eat right away.
  • Whole nuts and very hard pieces. Chop them first. Very hard items can stress the paddle; check your manual for anything it says to avoid.
  • Raw flour or raw egg. Use heat-treated flour for cookie dough.

Ribbons, swirls and combos to try

Sauces behave differently from chunks. The goal is a streak through the ice cream, not a flavored base, so temperature is everything.

  • Use thick sauces, like caramel, fudge or cookie butter. Thin syrups disappear into the base.
  • Chill them first. Sauce straight from the fridge stays in ribbons. Warm sauce melts the pint and blends in.
  • Fruit swirls must be cold and thick. Cook berries down into a jammy compote and chill it, as in our Blueberry Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream.
  • For more defined ribbons, some owners spoon the sauce in by hand after Mix-In instead of running it through the program.
  • Vanilla base with crushed cookies and a little cold fudge.
  • Chocolate base with peanut butter ribbons and mini chips.
  • Coffee base with chopped dark chocolate and toasted almonds.
  • Cheesecake-style base with graham pieces and a cold berry swirl.
  • Brown sugar base with toasted pecans and a pinch of flaky salt.

Keep the total around ¼ cup per 16 oz pint even when you combine several mix-ins, or the base won't hold them all.

Saving leftover pints with mix-ins

Pints with mix-ins can go back in the freezer. Smooth the top and put the lid on. When you Re-spin later, expect the chunks to break down further, so many owners add a fresh spoonful of mix-ins and run Mix-In again instead of a full Re-spin. Crunchy mix-ins like cookies slowly soften in the freezer, so they're best eaten within a day or two.

For more chunky pint ideas, browse the CREAMi recipe hub.

FAQ

When do I add mix-ins to the Ninja CREAMi?

After the pint has been spun smooth. Make a hole down the center, add the mix-ins and run the Mix-In program.

How many mix-ins can I add to a CREAMi pint?

About ¼ cup total for a 16 oz pint is a good starting point. Use a bit less for dense mix-ins like nuts and a bit more for light ones like marshmallows.

Can I put fresh fruit in as a mix-in?

You can, but dice it small. Big fresh fruit pieces freeze into hard, icy chunks. Cooked fruit or a cold compote works better.

Why did my mix-ins all end up on top?

They were probably piled on the surface. Dig a hole all the way to the bottom of the pint and put the mix-ins inside it before running Mix-In.

Recipes to try

More guides