Guides
Guide · Ninja CREAMi

High-Protein CREAMi Formula: The Base Ratio and How to Build It

The base ratio behind high-protein CREAMi pints: milk, protein, pudding mix and flavor, plus swaps, flavor-building and fixes so you can create your own.

By the Dalqi kitchen · Updated 2026-11-16 · 4 min read

Ingredients for protein ice cream laid out on a counter: carton of milk, scoop of protein powder, pudding mix, cocoa and a finished chocolate pint

Short answer

Most high-protein CREAMi pints follow one simple ratio for a 16 oz pint: about 1¾ cups (420 ml) ultra-filtered milk, 1 scoop (about 30 g) protein powder, 1 tablespoon (about 8 g) sugar-free instant pudding mix, a flavor and a pinch of salt. Shake, freeze 24 hours, spin on Lite Ice Cream and Re-spin with a splash of milk if needed. Change the flavor parts and keep the ratio, and you can build almost any protein pint you want.

The base ratio

PartAmount (16 oz pint)Job
Ultra-filtered milk1¾ cups / 420 mlThe liquid, plus extra protein
Protein powder1 scoop / about 30 gProtein and body
Sugar-free instant pudding mix1 tbsp / about 8 gThickener; stops iciness
Dry flavor (cocoa, espresso, spices)1 tsp to 1 tbspFlavor without extra water
Wet flavor (extract, syrup)1 tsp extract or 1 tbsp syrupAroma and sweetness
SaltA pinchMakes flavors taste brighter

This is the ratio behind our Vanilla Bean Protein Pint and most of the protein pints on the site. For a 24 oz Deluxe pint, multiply each amount by 1.5.

Why each part is there

Ultra-filtered milk is filtered to concentrate protein and reduce sugar. Depending on the brand, it has roughly half again as much protein per cup as regular milk, which is why it's the default in protein pints. Regular milk works too; you'll just get less protein.

Protein powder adds most of the protein and helps body. A whey-casein blend spins creamiest. Pure whey isolate works but tends to be lighter and icier.

Pudding mix is the quiet hero. It binds water so the pint doesn't spin icy or powdery. Use instant, not cook-and-serve.

Salt sounds odd in dessert, but a pinch makes vanilla, chocolate and caramel taste fuller, especially in lean bases.

How to build it, step by step

  1. Add the protein powder, pudding mix, dry flavors and salt to an empty pint.
  2. Pour in about half the milk. Lid on and shake hard for 30 seconds, or whisk until smooth.
  3. Add the rest of the milk and any wet flavors. Stir. Stay at or below the MAX line.
  4. Taste it. It should taste slightly sweeter and stronger than you want, since cold dulls flavor.
  5. Let foam settle, then freeze level with the lid on for 24 hours.
  6. Spin on Lite Ice Cream. If it's powdery, add 1 tablespoon of milk and Re-spin.
  7. Add mix-ins with the Mix-In program if you're using them.

Building your own flavors

Keep the base ratio the same and change three things: the protein flavor, the pudding flavor and the extras.

FlavorProteinPuddingExtras
ChocolateChocolateChocolate1 tbsp cocoa (recipe)
MochaChocolateChocolate or vanillaCold brew in place of some milk (recipe)
CheesecakeVanillaCheesecakeBerries, graham (recipe)
Cinnamon rollVanillaVanilla or butterscotchCinnamon, nutmeg (recipe)
Birthday cakeVanillaVanillaAlmond extract, sprinkles (recipe)
Pumpkin pieVanillaVanillaPumpkin, spice (recipe)

When you add a wet ingredient like coffee, fruit puree or pumpkin, take out about the same amount of milk so you stay under MAX and keep the ratio balanced.

Swaps and what they change

  • Almond or other thin plant milk: fewer calories and less protein, but icier. Add a little extra pudding mix and plan on a Re-spin, as in our Under-200-Calorie Vanilla Pint.
  • Regular 2% or whole milk: creamier, but less protein than ultra-filtered.
  • Greek yogurt for part of the milk: more protein and a thick, tangy texture.
  • No protein powder: use Greek yogurt or blended cottage cheese, as in the Greek Yogurt Vanilla Pint.
  • A spoon of cream cheese or cream: richer, softer, more calories.
  • Sweetener: if your powder isn't very sweet, add allulose or a sugar-free syrup. Allulose keeps the pint softer than erythritol.

Troubleshooting your own formula

ProblemChange this
Powdery after spinningRe-spin with 1 tbsp milk; next time add a little fat or switch to a blend
Icy and crunchyMore pudding mix (up to 1½ tbsp), less watery liquid
Gummy or starchyLess pudding mix
ChalkyMix more thoroughly; try a different powder
BlandMore salt, stronger extract, sweeter base
Too thick to pour before freezingCasein-heavy powder; add a splash more milk

Change one thing at a time. If you change three things and the pint gets better, you won't know which one did it.

Use the pint builder to check macros

Protein and calories depend heavily on your exact milk and powder, so we don't quote one number for every pint. Our pint builder lets you pick a milk, a protein, a thickener and extras and shows the protein and calories for the whole pint as you go. It's the fastest way to see whether a swap is worth it before you freeze anything.

For tested versions of the formula in dozens of flavors, see the protein section of our CREAMi recipe hub.

FAQ

What is the basic ratio for CREAMi protein ice cream?

For a 16 oz pint: about 1¾ cups ultra-filtered milk, 1 scoop of protein powder, 1 tablespoon of sugar-free instant pudding mix, flavoring and a pinch of salt.

Can I add two scoops of protein to a CREAMi pint?

It's not usually a good idea. The base gets very thick and can spin chalky or dense. Use ultra-filtered milk or Greek yogurt for extra protein instead.

How do I make CREAMi protein ice cream without protein powder?

Replace the powder and part of the milk with Greek yogurt or blended cottage cheese. Both add protein and make a creamy pint.

Which program should I use for a protein pint?

Lite Ice Cream. Then Re-spin with about a tablespoon of milk if the pint looks powdery.

How do I scale the formula for a CREAMi Deluxe?

Multiply every ingredient by 1.5 for a 24 oz pint and fill only to the MAX line.

Recipes to try

More guides